Affirmative Action is a Step
Toward Increasing Diversity
The Editorial Board
This past week, President Peter Stanley announced that Pomona
College-along with other selective liberal arts schools across
the nation-has added its name to amicus curiae brief which
is being filed in the controversial Supreme Court cases the
University of Michigan is involved in Gratz V. Bollinger,
et al and Grutter V. Bollinger et al.
It isn't everyday that we witness Pomona declaring an official
side on such a decidedly political issue; however, the right
of colleges to use race as a factor in admissions is apparently
important enough to prompt 28 similar selective, small schools
to file a brief. We applaud Pomona's decision to support affirmative
action.
However, despite Pomona's professed desire for cultural and
racial diversity, the school still has a significant amount
of work to do in order to achieve its goal; a large percentage
of our population still consists of white, wealthy prep school
students.
As the brief states, having a student body made up of varied
cultures and races allows for students to educate each other
(both in and out of the classroom) in different, and more
comprehensive ways than would otherwise happen. Still, for
whatever reason, the number of minority students enrolled
at Pomona is still too low.
The admissions office is certainly active in recruiting more
minority students to apply. Especially in the local Los Angeles
area high schools, Pomona ensures that there are admissions
or alumni representatives targeting and recruiting students.
Once minority students are admitted, there are special prospective
weekends for them to come stay at Pomona; the Admissions office
even ensures that part of the minority prospective weekend
consists of discussion about what it means to be a student
of color at the Claremont Colleges.
So why do we see the numbers of minority students rising
so slowly?
Perhaps it has something to do with the experience of minority
students who do end up enrolling at Pomona. In recent years,
there has been much debate about the tendency of minority
students to segregate themselves into "racial cliques."
People tend to get emotional about this trend, which often
prevents the issue from being examined more deeply.
Instead of different groups accusing each other of isolating
themselves, the Pomona community must examine why minority
students might feel that need for separation. This discussion
often tends to happen at Chicano/Latino Student Association,
Office of Black Student Affairs or Pan-African Student Association
retreats, but not always at Pomona as a whole. Is it a desire
of some minority students to feel more comfortable with people
who share their same racial and cultural experience, or is
this an indication that Pomona is not doing all it can to
promote an environment that allows for a healthy diversity?
How many minority students are involved in campus organizations,
committees, or positions in leadership? Is there an effort
being made by Senate, fraternities, or sports teams to appeal
to all members of the student body? Although CLSA (and the
other similar organizations) might provide a sponsor to go
talk to about the feelings and problems that are part of a
minority student's experience, there are other fundamental
issues that are tied up with racial diversity that are not
being addressed.
One example of a problem that gets overlooked is financial
aid. Although Pomona is one of the most generous liberal arts
schools when it comes to providing financial aid, there are
financial considerations which the school doesn't always to
example. For the minority students who come from economically
disadvantaged backgrounds, there are expenses that financial
aid does not cover, such as books or materials needed for
class.
While most people obtain work-study jobs to pay for their
personal expenses, that too can become a problem: how many
students are struggling to balance their intense academic
load with work-study jobs that can take up 18 hours of their
time?
These types of problems are not solely tied to race and affirmative
action; we need more diversity in terms of geography, economic
background, sexual preference and academic concentrations.
These problems are multi-faceted and there is no easy solution.
By filing the amicus curiae brief Pomona is making a proactive
step in affirming its commitment to diversity.
|